Lisa
Now that you have the site running again, I'd advise checking the extensionless-configuration in IIS before applying the changes to have the 'No extension' setting turned on.
You can configure your site for no-extensions in IIS, configure Url Master but with 'Always Use' as the extension handling option , then just request one of your pages without an extension ; for example - http://scienceofbusiness.com/consulting_services/ With Url Master handling the Urls, requesting this Url should work. It will probably 301 redirect to /consulting_services.aspx, but if you don't get the IIS thrown 404, then you know you've got the configuration correctly set up.
Once you've got the site responding to extension-less Urls, then you can configure the 'Never' option of the Extensions setting.